Search the corpus

    A $p$-cycle and a transposition generate $S_p$ for $p$ prime

    P-MXATB

    Area
    Algebra
    Topics
    Conjugacy, Group Presentations, Permutations
    Status
    draft

    Let \(p\) be prime, let \(\sigma\in S_p\) be a \(p\)-cycle, and let \(\tau\in S_p\) be any transposition. Show that \[ \langle\sigma,\tau\rangle=S_p. \]

    Solution

    Label the \(p\) points by the additive group \(\ZZ/p\ZZ\) so that \[ \sigma(x)=x+1. \] Write \[ \tau=(a,b), \qquad d=b-a\ne0\pmod p. \]

    For every \(k\in\ZZ/p\ZZ\), \[ \sigma^k\tau\sigma^{-k}=(a+k,b+k). \] Thus the subgroup \(H=\langle\sigma,\tau\rangle\) contains the transposition joining \(x\) to \(x+d\) for every \(x\in\ZZ/p\ZZ\).

    Consider the graph with vertex set \(\ZZ/p\ZZ\) and edges \[ \{x,x+d\}. \] Because \(p\) is prime and \(d\ne0\), the element \(d\) generates the additive group \(\ZZ/p\ZZ\). Hence this graph is connected (indeed it is a \(p\)-cycle).

    The transpositions corresponding to the edges of any connected graph on \(p\) vertices generate the full symmetric group: a spanning tree suffices, since transpositions along the unique path from a fixed root to a vertex generate the star transpositions, and star transpositions generate \(S_p\).

    Therefore the conjugates of \(\tau\) already generate \(S_p\), and hence \[ \langle\sigma,\tau\rangle=S_p. \]